The Konanykhine case
The New American Magazine
February 1, 2004
Alexander Konanykhine is a wildly successful 37-year-old Russian expatriate entrepreneur. The U.S. government has accused him -- on the basis of supposed evidence provided by Russian investigators -- of being an embezzler, a bigamist, and a draft dodger. Konanykhine's background is somewhat murky, perhaps even troubling, but this much is certain: He is a man who blew the whistle on the KGB's continuing stranglehold on Russia, particularly its banking industry. For this, the government of KGB veteran Vladimir Putin wants Konanykhine dead - and our Department of Homeland Security has done its best to give Moscow a helping hand.
Konanykhine and his wife Elena have lived in the United States since 1992. His first act upon arrival in New York was to contact the FBI and the Russian government (including a personal letter to then-President Boris Yeltsin) requesting an investigation of his business, the All-Russian Exchange Bank, which had been seized from him by KGB-connected Russian mobsters.
In early 1995, the FBI informed the young banker that the Russian mob -- which is an operational arm of the KGB -- had issued a contract on his life. But within a few months of that warning, the FBI began to collaborate in a Russian investigation of Konanykhine on charges of embezzlement. In June 1996, officials from the Immigration and Naturalization Service, in a joint operation with agents of the re-named KGB arrested Konanykhine and raided his apartment in Washington's Watergate complex. The KGB accused him of falsifying his employment history, thereby invalidating his visa. This cleared the way for Konanykhine's expulsion to Russia, where he faced imprisonment, torture, and death.
"In my country, I grew up fearing the KGB," Konanykhine told The New American while in federal detention. "I had nightmares of KGB agents breaking down my door in the middle of the night, arresting me, and hauling me away to prison. That never happened to me in Russia. But it happened to me here in America."
Following Konanykhine's 1996 arrest, Nickolai Menchukov, one of his business associates, tried to intervene with the INS. According to court documents, an INS supervisor "threatened Mr. Menchukov with arrest without so much as thinking of a pretext." This threat was reiterated three weeks later when Menchukov testified on his friend's behalf at a federal court hearing.
Russian efforts to silence Menchukov were even more forceful. As Konanykhine explained in a 1997 interview with The New American, "When you provoke the Russian mafia and the KGB, they don't just retaliate against you, they retaliate against your family and friends."
Shortly after Menchukov came forward, his mother-in-law was visited by Russian security agents. A few days after Menchukov testified, his brother-in-law was mysteriously gunned down in Russia. "In Russia today, it is the same terror system of the old days, just with different people," Menchukov lamented.
In 1997, Federal District Court Judge T.S. Ellis III ruled that the case against Konanykhine was based on corrupt, KGB-provided evidence and ordered the Department of Justice to pay $100,000 in legal fees. John Milo Bryant, a United States immigration judge in Arlington, Virginia, subsequently ruled that Konanykhine and his wife "have a well-founded fear of persecution on account of their political opinion if they are returned to Russia" and therefore "have met the statutory requirement for a grant of asylum."
One of those who testified on behalf of Konanykhine was KGB defector Yuri Shvets, who declared: "I have a firsthand knowledge on similar operations conducted by the KGB." Konanykhine had brought trouble on himself, Shvets continued, when he "started bringing charges against people who were involved with him in setting up and running commercial enterprises. They were KGB people … secretly smuggling from Russia hundreds of millions of dollars…. This is [a] serious case, and I know that KGB ... desperately wants to win this case, and everybody who won't step to their side would face problems."
Statements such as these prompted U.S. District Judge Ellis, who presided at the hearing, to interject: "I thought the KGB ceased to exist after the Soviet Union was dissolved. Is that not right?" "No, your honor, it is not correct," replied Shvets. "It exists, even though it has changed the name. The same people, the same tasks. The United States is, again, the main adversary. They are keeping spying on the United States, and this is the same repressive domestic agency."
A settlement with the INS allowed Konanykhine and his wife to remain in this country. After becoming the first Russian expatriates to receive asylum from "post-Soviet" Russia, the couple began the process of becoming U.S. citizens. They also filed a substantial wrongful arrest suit against the INS. This certainly didn’t endear them to Washington. A few months ago, Konanykhine's Russian enemies resumed their efforts to drag him back to that country.
In late 2003, the Russian government began an aggressive campaign against a group of tainted businessmen commonly called the "oligarchs." This included the arrest of 40-year-old Mikhail Khordokovsky, a banker reputed to be Russia's wealthiest man -- and a one-time business partner of Konanykhine.
This was essentially a turf war between different ruling factions in Russia. "Putin's team has a lot of power, but they're hungry for more," Konanykhine explained to The New American. "They went after Khordokovsky's whole team, which gave them an excuse to pressure Washington to expel me back to Russia."
On November 20, Konanykhine's asylum was revoked. Acting on the advice of his immigration attorney, Michael Maggio, Konanykhine decided to travel to Canada with his wife to consult with authorities there about receiving asylum. Trying to cross the border on December 18, the couple was swarmed by a dozen federal agents. Within an hour, they were taken to the Russian consulate in Washington, where arrangements had been made to fly them back to Russia.
Literally minutes before the couple was to be stuffed on a Moscow-bound plane, Judge Ellis issued an emergency stay of deportation in order to review the case. According to Maggio, sending Konanykhine back to Russia would be tantamount to a death sentence. "Here we have a case where literally a man's life is in question," Maggio told Judge Ellis. "I have lost deportation cases before, but I have never had a case where I had to really worry about someone dying."
If the federal government's desire was to expel Konanykhine from the country, why wasn't he allowed to go to Canada, which had indicated its willingness to take him in? Why the insistence on turning him over to the Russians? The conduct of federal authorities in this case, Maggio observed, was akin to that of East German border guards, and the seizure of Konanykhine and his wife at the Canadian border was "reminiscent of a movie about the Cold War with freedom right in sight and he gets grabbed…."
Washington's determination to hand Konanykhine over to Russia, concluded Judge Ellis in a hearing late last year, reflected a "sinister deal between the INS and the successors to the KGB. There's no treaty between Russia and the U.S., and they wanted this guy back for some reason, and the U.S. also wanted an FBI office in Moscow, and so they dealt. It was that simple."
"This has all the earmarks of something strange," commented Judge Ellis during a hearing last December. "I don't understand what's happening with this man and Russia and our country."
Part of the explanation may be simple, corrupt opportunism on the part of the Department of Homeland Security (which is now in control of the INS). "The INS knew that I would be killed in Russia," Konanykhine told The New American. Pointing to the fact that he has a $100,000,000 wrongful arrest lawsuit pending against the INS (and, by extension, the DHS), Konanykhine wryly comments: "Certainly, eliminating the plaintiff is the most effective way to avoid a lawsuit. The question is -- shall the U.S. Government be allowed to kill people to avoid judicial review?"
But this entire affair has its roots in the growing convergence of the U.S. and "post-Soviet" Russia -- a misbegotten marriage symbolized by the July 4, 1994 FBI-KGB cooperation pact signed in Moscow by then-FBI Director Louis Freeh. Konanykhine is a young man who had ascended to the rarefied heights of the Russian nomenklatura, or ruling class. He was part of Boris Yeltsin's inner circle, surrounded by the KGB-aligned figures who have plundered Russia, often with the help of U.S. subsidies.
As Yuri Shvets pointed out, Konanykhine's troubles began when he blew the whistle on this racket. That's why both Moscow and Washington want him dead.
Thank you for listening. Please join us again next time.